Cigna International Health Insurance

Parenting Style: Far East vs. The West

By Brian O'Sullivan

Summary: Author and Blogger Brian O'Sullivan helps expats examine the differences in parenting that exist in Western and Far Eastern cultures. Emotional self-regulation and self-recoginition are a few of the topics he explores.

Expats and Parenting - Parenting Style:  Far East vs. The West

When visiting foreign countries it's easy for expats to make simple observations and then form theories based off those observations. It's in our nature. Sometimes we're right, but often times we're far off. Culture is extremely complex and ever changing, making it that much more important in taking our time when coming to our own conclusions or trusting the theories of fellow expats.

Japan is no exception to this. Often times Westerners visiting Japan will notice how well-behaved, calm and independent Japanese children appear to be (e.g., little fuss when falling down or walking quietly alone at a very young age). Our Western minds love answers, so we start hypothesizing: "It must be strict parenting" or "Japanese parents don't show as much affection to their children, making kids less dependent on their parents."

Hedi Keller, a German psychologist did some interesting studies, comparing parenting in the West and East. What she found is very interesting.

Proximal vs. distal

Japanese parents tend to adopt a proximal parenting style. Proximal parenting is just as it sounds: close. Through things like co-sleeping, co-bathing, and tight living conditions, mother and baby are always near one another. Even more important than this is the heavy touch between mother and child. This consistent and prolong skin contact even has its own word: "Skinship," pronounced "Skinushipu" in Japanese.

The heavy touch at home may be surprising to foreigners who consistently observe thick boundaries and a lack of touch in Japan.

While in Japan proximal parenting is the norm, in the West distal parenting is more common. Distal parenting is just the opposite of proximal. Not to say that touch doesn't happen, but that other things become more of the focus. For example, during play, Western parents tend to focus their children attention on objects, words, and eye contact than they do on touch (relative to Japan).

Western parents also tend to spend more time physically away from their children than in Japan. In fact, Fred Rothbaum and others found that during the first 2 years of a child's life, American mothers spend approximately 24 hours every week away from their children (working, date nights, etc.), while Japanese mothers spend only 2 hours every week away from their child (this is changing however, as more Japanese women are becoming more powerful and gaining more respect in the workforce).

What's even more interesting is the outcome from these different parenting styles.

Self-regulation vs. self-recognition

Keller found a heavy correlation between proximal parenting and the early development of self-regulation, and between distal parenting and the early development of self-recognition. So, what does this mean?

Self-regulation is the ability to control one's own emotions and behaviors. Take for example the marshmallow test:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QX_oy9614HQ.

Or take a look at the show Hajimete No Ostukai, or "My First Errand," which is a popular Japanese reality show that follows incredibly young children who have been assigned a task by their parent, requiring the child or two siblings to go out in to town alone:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5k5XTZy0rA

Self-recognition, on the other hand, is the ability to recognize a self exists. So, this means that one recognizes that his or her feelings differ from others and vice versa. It means that one recognizes that he or she has influence over the environment (e.g., I cry and mom brings me food). Take for example, the mirror test:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2I0kwSua44.

In short, Japanese children become better at controlling their emotions and behaviors earlier on than Western children do. So, things like increased patience or less fuss when falling can be expected in the Far East.

In the West, children are experts at being individuals, expressing and asserting themselves, and shaping their environments more so than children from Japan.

Proactively Preventing Fuss vs Expressing Needs

In Japan, mothers focus their attention on meeting the needs of their child before they exist. This is of course challenging, but not as challenging as it would be for a Western parent, given the fact that Japanese mothers are rarely away from their child. So, it can be said that in general, Japanese children have fewer reasons to fuss or cry because they know mother is usually there before they even need her.

Western parents tend to label this aspect of the Japanese parenting style as spoiling. In addition, to not allow a child to express their needs by fussing or crying is to neglect them of an opportunity to learn independence, communication, and assertiveness, all of which are heavily valued in the West.

Examining the differences in the parenting styles between these two very different cultures not only brings to light some new and interesting concepts, but may also help to highlight some of our own values that can often go unexamined and assumed. It also reminds us of the benefits and dangers from generalizing.

Generalizing helps to look at a culture as a whole and to tease out important differences between different groups of people. It helps us to learn about others and brings more awareness to our own values, which can often go undetected and assumed.

But, it can also reinforce stereotypes and cause us to assume a lot about others we meet. It's important to realize that not all Japanese fit into the proximal parenting style, just as not all Americans fit nicely into the distal parenting style.

About the Author

AS Brian OSullivanBrian O'Sullivan is currently pursuing a master's degree in counseling psychology. He spends his time between San Francisco and Okinawa, Japan, blogging and studying cross-cultural and expatriate issues. You can find him at his website, www.brianlosullivan.com, or on twitter, @BriansBlogger.

Cigna International Health Insurance

Write a Comment about this Article

Sign In to post a comment.

Comments about this Article

guest
Feb 29, 2016 19:05

Fascinating article! I am currently living in the Andes mountains of Ecuador, and have family members who live in Japan. I have observed many, many similarities in parenting style between the Japanese and the Indigenous Indians of the Andes. I wonder how many other cultures around the world have similar parenting patterns?

First Published: Feb 24, 2016

Expatriate Health Insurance

Get a quote for expat health insurance from our partner, Cigna Global Health.
Get a Quote

Culture-Shock-in-HastingsAn Expat Talks about Culture Shock & Living in Hastings, Barbados

An expat in Barbados talks about what it's like living on this beautiful island. Adjusting to a more laid-back lifestyle isn't always as easy as you'd think, but can be liberating. Friday nights at the Oistins fish fry are a must!

An expat in Barbados talks about what it's like living on this beautiful island. Adjusting to a more laid-back lifestyle isn't always as easy as you'd think, but can be liberating. Friday nights at ...

Living-in-SantiagoAn Expat Discusses Living in Santiago, Chile

An expat who has lived in Santiago, Chile for 23 years talks about how the city has changed due to immigration and the fact that fewer people are religious.

An expat who has lived in Santiago, Chile for 23 years talks about how the city has changed due to immigration and the fact that fewer people are religious. ...

Moving to Norway

Expats in Norway report a life abroad in a country to which it can be difficult to adapt. However, if you have the right situation and persevere, the natural beauty and hard won quality friendships can be quite rewarding.

Expats in Norway report a life abroad in a country to which it can be difficult to adapt. However, if you have the right situation and persevere, the natural beauty and hard won quality friendships ca...

Healthcare in the UK

Expats in the U.K. are able to utilize the public health care system, which is managed by the NHS. Many expats want to have private health insurance to help reduce wait times and several other reasons. Read for more details on how to navigate the system.

Expats in the U.K. are able to utilize the public health care system, which is managed by the NHS. Many expats want to have private health insurance to help reduce wait times and several other reason...

Expats in Guatemala: Pros and Cons of Living in Guatemala

Expats are very forthcoming about the pros and cons of living in Guatemala. Pros include the spring-like weather, the low cost of living and the lifestyle. Cons include limited access to quality healthcare (especially outside of Guatemala City), gringo pricing, crime and the reality that the rainy season can be depressing.

Expats are very forthcoming about the pros and cons of living in Guatemala. Pros include the spring-like weather, the low cost of living and the lifestyle. Cons include limited access to quality hea...

Copyright 1997-2019 Burlingame Interactive, Inc.

Privacy Policy Legal