So we found a nice place in Cuenca to rent and it's not under the broken bridge. It's a nice 4 bedroom in a secure and safe neighborhood for under $280 a month.
Here is a tip. Stay away from brokers, they round up their rent numbers to the nearest $100 or $200 at your expense. Walk neighborhoods you like, bring someone bi-lingual or hire one of those Cuenca consultants for a few hours.It would be worth it. The place we found was not advertised. Apparently the reason being, and this is not a confirmed fact, but some Ecuadorians don't like to rent to locals.